The Rocky TiVo-DirecTV Relationship 219
Thomas Hawk writes "Phillip Swann's TV Predictions is out this morning alleging that before dumping their TiVo stock last year, Rupert Murdoch's DirecTV had made a pass at buying a controlling stake in TiVo. According to Swann, 'TiVo's top management did not like Murdoch's offer,' and Swann alleges that this is why you had a fallout between the two companies. As an interesting aside, Rob Pegoraro over at the Washington Post was out yesterday warning people to not buy an HDTV TiVo, as DirecTV will be changing their high-def signal later this year and that if you bought the HDTV TiVo that you might not be able to watch network TV in high def. As an owner of one of those expensive high-def DirecTV TiVos, I sure hope this isn't the case."
YAFM (Yet Another Fine Mirror) (Score:5, Informative)
Thomas Hawk [networkmirror.com] writes "Phillip Swann's TV Predictions is out this morning alleging that before dumping their TiVo stock last year, Rupert Murdoch's DirecTV had made a pass at buying a controlling stake in TiVo [networkmirror.com]. According to Swann, 'TiVo's top management did not like Murdoch's offer,' and Swann alleges that this is why you had a fallout between the two companies. As an interesting aside, Rob Pegoraro over at the Washington Post was out yesterday warning people to not buy an HDTV TiVo [networkmirror.com], as DirecTV will be changing their high-def signal later this year and that if you bought the HDTV TiVo that you might not be able to watch network TV in high def. As an owner of one of those expensive high-def DirecTV TiVos, I sure hope this isn't the case."
When will they (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:When will they (Score:3, Insightful)
As soon as planned obsolesence becomes illegal.
Re:When will they (Score:2)
Re:When will they (Score:5, Interesting)
There is only two "formats" of TiVo for DirecTV, the normal ones that record the stream from the sat, and the new HDTV TiVo's that cost a grand. So I don't see why you would have to buy a new one every "6-8 months" as you suggest.
If you call them now and inquire about a DVR they direct you to the new home entertainment unit that will be coming out soon
Re:When will they (Score:3, Informative)
Re:When will they (Score:2)
Re:When will they (Score:2)
Plus, there's the issue that the HD Tivo can't handle Ka signals, so it wouldn't even be able to receive the MPEG-4 stream in the first place.
Bottom line: the current HD Tivo will not work with DirecTV's new HD rollout.
Re:When will they (Score:2)
DirecTV's DVR is still vaporware (Score:2)
DirecTV is coming out with their own DVR that will be some kind of home entertainment thing.
Let's keep in mind that DirecTV has only announced a DVR system (to be built by News Corp subsidiary and fellow Murdoch-empire-stablemate NDS), but hasn't yet delivered a product, and the ship date continues to slip. It'll be interesting to see what they come up with, but if the current level of competition is any indication, TiVo will still have a superior UI and more robust scheduling system.
Re:DirecTV's DVR is still vaporware (Score:2)
Re:When will they (Score:4, Insightful)
While I work in the biz (but none of sky/dtv/tivo) I'd guess that Sky are making DTV switch to DVB so all their gear is interoperable
Re:When will they (Score:2)
Re:When will they (Score:2)
Re:When will they (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:When will they (Score:4, Informative)
-Em
Re:When will they (Score:2)
No, it doesn't record HD, but at the moment I'm willing to live with that, seeing as how my other choice seems to be to spend hundreds on a machine that might not record HD anyway.
Re:When will they (Score:2)
-Em
Re:One way to fix it (Score:3, Insightful)
it's true (Score:5, Informative)
A couple of good sites to find more info are:
http://www.dbsforums.com [dbsforums.com]
http://www.dbstalk.com [dbstalk.com]
http://www.tivocommunity.com [tivocommunity.com]
Re:it's true (Score:2)
Re:it's true (Score:3, Informative)
They're doing both. (Score:4, Informative)
It's likely that they will offer you a replacement box (although this is just me speculating) for free or at a steep discount, since those of you with the HD-Tivo are highend customers. Unfortunately for the Tivo faithful, it won't be a Tivo.
Re:They're doing both. (Score:2)
Re:They're doing both. (Score:2)
That's a bit of a drag, to say the least. I wonder if there's still time for them to change their minds if I point out to them that this policy will
HD Tivo is obsolete (Score:5, Insightful)
Wikify:HD Tivo is obsolete (Score:2, Informative)
Re:HD Tivo is obsolete (Score:2)
cablecard (Score:5, Interesting)
As far as I know, there's no cablecard equivalent for satellite boxes, but there should be. Ahh, the incredible balance between freedom and regulation.
Re:cablecard (Score:5, Insightful)
With the repeated granting of 1-year extensions on the CableCard deadline, don't hold your breath waiting for it. We still don't have all the HD content that was FCC mandated...
Re:cablecard (Score:2)
Time Warner seems to be a pretty good company all around. My internet access is awesome, the dvr is awesome, and they haven't ever gone up on my rates.
Re:cablecard (Score:2, Informative)
There is no FCC mandate of HDTV content. The FCC has asked nicely, with a cherry on top, that broadcasters produce and deploy HDTV in hopes that the 15% of the US population that currently receives their TV content from NTSC broadcasts would go out and get a shiny new digital TV that can recieve and decode the mandated ATSC digital broadcast signal and the HDTV feature in supposed to entice that portion of the population to do so.
Note: Those broadcasts are not required to be HDTV. They can be S
Re:cablecard (Score:2)
The FCC mandated a switch to digital (not HDTV per se, although it is heavily being used for it), which was repeatedly appealed and postponed.
Re:cablecard (Score:2)
NTSC defines a picture format. All television signals broadcast or received in the US are NTSC signals except for ATSC broadcasts.
Re:cablecard (Score:5, Informative)
the Cable companies do NOT hate the cablecard. It's motorola, Scientifica Atlanta and Jerrold as well as other sattelite and Catv headend gear makers.
all of them REFUSE to follow any standards and intercooperate to ensure headend and plant lock-in on cable companies. If you are an all motorola cable company you haveto throw away EVERYTHING to use any SA gear. Motorola Loves that. SA does the same damn thing.
the cablecard gives up the monopoly of locking in the cable companies to a single vendor for their headend gear.
the rest of the world uses a single standard... the US has several that are bastardized by each equipment makes to ensure there is no interoperability.
so take your cabletv company hating LIES and go elsewhere.
if you want cablecard to exist then tell Motorola to quit fighting it as well as the other equipment makers.
if they ran the damned DVB standard like the rest of the world this all would be a non issue.
Re:cablecard (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:cablecard (Score:3)
Was it, like mine and many others, a faux-wood-panelled box with two red LED numbers? Was that box 10-15 years old, long since paid for, and you were still charged $5-10 for it? Remember how they charged you extra for the remote?
You can't tell me that by renting out all those ancient Jerrolds and General Instruments boxes, the cable company wasn't making a profit on hardware rental.
The brave new world of cablecos losing
Re:cablecard (Score:3, Informative)
Re:cablecard (Score:4, Informative)
However, at the same time, cable operators are afraid of CableCard. The advantage of freeing them up to use any frontend that they want also scares them. At least by forging a relationship with Motorola or SA, they can get their boxes branded and control the content. With CableCard, anybody can make a set-top box, with no branding, no advertising lock-in, and no guaranteed content protection.
What I would really love to see is a PCI card that accepts a CableCard, which can be used to decrypt the digital cable content. Not so that I can spread the shows around the Internet, but so that I can use the features of my MythTV machine. (Yes, the content has to be decrypted for MythTV to really make any use of it, otherwise the PCI card has to have video out. MythTV would still lose the OSD feature, and it would be harder to configure.)
Microsoft might be the closest ally on that, since they'll need a way to capture digital cable content for their Media Center platform (if they wish to continue that).
-- Joe
Re:cablecard (Score:2)
Who knew the cable companies had rabid fans? That's wild.
Re:cablecard (Score:2)
I misspoke about HDTV, really meaning the FCC mandate to move to digital broadcast; we have a difference of opinion about cablecos and their hardware (see my other post on the faux-wood boxes).
As far as the opening and tone of the response - it's all good. This is slashdot. One geek's Flamebait is another geek's Insightful.
Re:cablecard (Score:2)
I disagree with your assertion that the ATSC that is used in the US is somehow... Americanized or has become an American specific standard. Yes, there are some devices out there that don't
NON HDTV worth anything? (Score:3, Insightful)
We should have had digital signals 100% several years ago... the specs were designed to allow nearly 7 years of dual broadcasting overlap...but all that time has been squandered. You were supposed to be able to buy a DTV-to-analog converter for $50 years a
Re:cablecard (Score:4, Interesting)
I had a SA TiVo on cable for a while. I had the old style box with an IR Blaster and it worked fine, never missed a show or had any issues with it.
Most digital cable boxes can be controled with the serial cable from the TiVo to increase speed and reliablility.
The DirecTiVo units record the stream from the sats, so they are incompatible for that reason. But they give you PERFECT quality, something the SA TiVo's can't do.
The signals will probably always be different between cable and sat, so I don't know what they could do. I see a future where cable companies use different encoding for their streams, making the cablecard worthless anyway :(
This is Business news, really. (Score:5, Insightful)
With TiVo selling out to Comcast and pushing pop-up ads, I can't feel much positive about them anymore.
Foxblocking Tivo? (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Foxblocking Tivo? (Score:3)
Re:Foxblocking Tivo? (Score:2)
IF you're watching fox, its sticking your hands in your ears and going NYAAAAA when someone says something that isnt true.
Rules of Acquisition. (Score:2)
Quark? Is that you? No one else I know who can put their hands in their own ears. I guess you get pretty sore when Neil Cavuto talks down your investment companies, don't you?
Answers to Foxblocking (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Answers to Foxblocking (Score:2)
Re:Answers to Foxblocking (Score:2)
Are you conservative? (Score:2)
According to what you said, you must be a conservative, obviously. No one who knows anything about science and technology would think that it would take a scientist to market a simple TV channel filter. I bet you think that auto factory line workers and lipstick saleswomen are all scientists too!
Times they are a changin... (Score:5, Insightful)
But it is the *ONLY* box that does what it does. 2 OTA tuners, 2 Satellite Tuners, both OTA and Satellite HD...
But Mpeg4 is coming, and this box has NO way to deal with it. And even as an owner of the box, I welcome MPEG4, as this will give me what I really want... Not "digital quality", but "quality digital". Replacing all of the boxes out there is cheaper than building and launching a satellite. HD will be where they go first, but eventually ALL DirectTV will be mpeg4.
I am sad that there was a breakdown between Tivo and DirectTV, because the combo *is* the best way to watch tv today.
There is some promise apparantly for us HDTiVo folks to replace our boxes with something "as good or better". We shall see when it happens. For now, I LOVE my HDTiVo.
Re:Times they are a changin... (Score:4, Interesting)
Can you record your OTA HD channels with the HDTiVo?
Re:Times they are a changin... (Score:3, Interesting)
Yes.
Re:Times they are a changin... (Score:2)
My Comcast HD DVR has 2 tuners, and doesn't need an OTA setup since Comcast carries my local HD channels in their lineup. I only have to pay $5 a month, and when the box becomes obsolete I can swap it out for a new one.
Re:Times they are a changin... (Score:2)
They may even be doing it with software upgrades on existing hardware, but if they aren't, you can swap out the box for a new one whenever you want.
If only I didn't hate comcast so much.
Re:Times they are a changin... (Score:2)
Give in to the darkside. I did and now have the power of 6down/768up. Throw on Vonage and you can get rid of your phone company. Now you only have to deal with one utility service instead of two.
not much of an issue (Score:2)
To me, this is another example where "early adopters" get burnt, but the masses will not even notice. I've owned my Tivo since something like 2001 and used it exclusively with analog cable. I suspect there are a lot of us out there. Probably more than there are HD subscribers with HD Tivos. I'm just not persuaded that I need HDTV and I'm happy to hold off on getting one until it's the cheap standard that costs the same as normal TV's cost now.
By that time, all this kind of stuff will be sorted.
seth
Re:not much of an issue (Score:2)
Re:Times they are a changin... (Score:2)
You mean the only TiVo box to that? The motorola HDTV+DVR box I have from Comcast has dual HD tuners. The interface is not as pretty as TiVo but for $10 a month and no upfront cost it has exceeded my expectations. I am not a big TV watcher so the 80 gigs is enough for me. The upfront cost for that 1 HDTV TiVo box would be insane for someone like me.
Pleasing customers (Score:5, Insightful)
Business before hate.
Yes it is true (Score:5, Informative)
I can't wait for the new formats! (Score:5, Funny)
Ku band, QPSK and MPEG-2 are alright. But
Ka band, 8PSK and MPEG-4 are clearly going to blow them all away! (At least until Ko Band, ¥PSK and MPEG-7 come out...)
Re:I can't wait for the new formats! (Score:2)
This is totally off message, but I have a very low opinion of standards bodies. I fall into the descriptive-not-normative camp. Codify what's already su
Re:I can't wait for the new formats! (Score:3)
Re:I can't wait for the new formats! (Score:3, Informative)
8PSK - A new modulation system that allows 3 bits to be represented instead of 2 with each sample. PSK uses the phase of the signal to encode data. QPSK uses 4 different "levels", 8PSK allows 8. This also translates into higher-bandwidth.
MPEG-4 - A new encoding system that provides better picture quality with less bandwidth.
So, what does this mean?
I misread the title... (Score:3, Funny)
Re:I misread the title... (Score:4, Funny)
Rocky & TiVo (Score:4, Funny)
Bullwinkle: Hey, Rocky! Watch me pull a TiVo out of this hat.
Rocky: That trick never works.
/Bullwinkle reaches in hat and pulls out MGM Lion's head.
MGM Lion: ROOOOOOOOOOAAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRR!!!
Bullwinkle: Oops. Guess I need a new hat.
No surprise (Score:4, Funny)
I get DirecTV HD, but there's no way I'm spending one dime on anything so close to bankruptcy [yahoo.com] as Tivo.
Re:No surprise (Score:4, Insightful)
Okay, I can't just let this dog lie undisturbed. TiVo is not close to bankruptcy, despite their misgivings on Wall Street. In fact, as of their last conference call, they are expecting to turn profitable by the end of this year. They intend to balance revenue from three streams: hardware, subscriptions, and ad sponsers. That's good news for TiVo faithful.
The bad news is that they plan to reach profitability by sacrificing the ideals which brought them the love in the first place. Their hardware gets less reliable each iteration and harder to hack (for your own software patches). They sell ad space on the interface top menu. And now they are beginning to push pop-up ads on their paying subscribers (while you fast-forward). The recent deal with Comcast will put some variation of TiVo software on Comcast DVRs, most likely with the pop-up ads.
It remains to be seen how losing 2/3 of their base from DirecTV (in 2007) will affect TiVo, but they should be profitable by then. Don't hate TiVo for 'dying' like BSD and Apple. Instead, hate TiVo for sacrificing their own ideals.
DirectTV TiVos safe (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:DirectTV TiVos safe (Score:4, Funny)
No way dude!
I'm complaining to Slashdot, as usual.
A little off topic. (Score:2, Insightful)
TIVO access to DirecTV (Score:3, Interesting)
It hasn't even helped with stand-alone Tivo! (Score:4, Informative)
I can't see why CableCard would help with satellite systems, since you can make the argument that the satellite signal format is a function of competitive advantage (channels, dish sizes, etc).
The real reason is that both Dish and DTV want their systems as incompatible as possible, as it is a barrier to migration to the competitive product.
I do like the idea, though, of an uber-smart 'cablecard' enabled Tivo that can tune digital cable, DTV and Dish simultaenously (presumably with two, self-aiming dishes).
Rumored Trade-in Plan for new HMCs (Score:5, Informative)
Here is the rumored trade-in plan to get the new HMCs. It is very generous but I hope they stick to it.
HMC Cost update.
Latest info:
Two base (HD HMC) units with different capacity.
1) 240 GB - $499 + $99 for SD units and $199 for HD remote units
2) 480 GB - $599 + $99 for SD units and $199 for HD remote units
Trade in Values:
HD-TiVo -> High capacity unit + 2 HD remote units
SD TiVo -> Low capacity Unit + 1 SD remote unit
SD Receiver -> Low Capacity unit and 1 SD for every three (3) SD receivers.
It's basically a price match. For example, if you have two SD TiVo's and an standard HD unit, you can obtain the High Capacity + 1 HD remote unit in exchange.
Values on units for trade in:
Standard SD Receiver - No value for HMC - 1 for 1 on SD remote units
Standard HD Receiver - Low cap HMC or 1 HD Remote unit
1 TiVo - Low Capacity HMC + SD Unit
2 TiVo - High Capacity HMC + SD Unit, or High Capacity + SD Unit
Dollar Value:
SD Receiver $99
HD Receiver $399
TiVo $199
HD TiVo - $899
Funny this should come up (Score:2)
Re:Funny this should come up (Score:2)
Comcast,/DirecTV Shuffle (Score:2)
When the DirecTV deals fell apart, TiVo had to go back to Comcast hat in hand, and beg to get the same deal that they could have probably improved upon.
Marketers need to learn... (Score:3, Insightful)
Let's take the recent commercial for Lime Coke. They have this neat little play on Harry Nilsson's classic song "Coconut", which is amusing already, and they made a cute little vignette out of it. But once I've seen it four or five times, I'm done. I never need to see it again. If I was going to try Lime Coke, and I was, I would already have tried it -- which I did -- and decided whether I wanted to continue buying it, which I do. The sale is over. Any *further* commercials they show me for Lime Coke are a complete waste of time. And that's a commercial that SUCCEEDS.
So when you start worrying about whether I'm going to skip your commercials and you won't get your money's worth, you need a reality check. I don't watch your commercials ANYWAY. When your commercials come on, I will either watch them -- the first couple of times -- or else I will converse with my wife, go to the bathroom, check my email, or grab a snack from the kitchen.
I am not going to sit and watch your commercials no matter WHAT you do. The most you can do is force me to wait for what I actually *want* to be doing, during which time I will be annoyed and impatient and looking at your product's name. How do you think I'm going to feel when I see your product in a store? Why, I'll feel annoyed and impatient, of course. And that *doesn't* translate to increased sales.
10-250's over-the-air tuners (Score:2)
As for DirecTV introducing their own HD DVR, I'll believe it when I see it. I've been disappointed before by DVRs that are
Stop The Madness (Score:3, Funny)
I lost an uncle in the Beta Wars.
My dad lost his site and the use of his left arm in the Laser Disc campaigns.
And yet, the brave are marching out again to an expensive and certain death in the HDTV campaigns.
And meanwhile the rich get richer.
It is true (Score:2, Informative)
Re:No problem. (Score:5, Informative)
Re:No problem. (Score:5, Funny)
pffft. Running water. All of you people out there with your runner water are just rotting your minds and bodies. In my family, we read books and discuss philosophy while making the 3/4 mile trek to our well. We don't use running water, and we're better people for it. Don't even get me started on electicity and your demon antibiotics.
Re:No problem. (Score:3, Funny)
I love the smell of.... (Score:4, Funny)
I love the smell of self-immolating grammar nazis in the morning.
Re:Murdoch will ace you for money (Score:2)
Re:Murdoch will ace you for money (Score:3, Funny)
Blech.
Re:Murdoch will ace you for money (Score:2)
The other poster was also intelligent enough not to flame about sentence structure while misspelling "sentence."
Re:TV? What is that? (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:TV? What is that? (Score:4, Insightful)
Likewise, I'm not a better person because I choose not to drink alcohol. Does not drinking alcohol give me more time to pursue more "noble" activities each week that is unclouded by alcoholic distractions? Absolutely. However, so would a number of other choices like avoiding Slashdot. Is my wife a better person than you because she abstains from participating on this site? No.
TV is one form of entertainment out of many. And, despite the deep longings and ideal dreams of the anti-TV elite, removing televisions from homes will not result in 230 million Americans suddenly picking up Tolstoy. Rather, they'd simply turn to other forms of entertainment that demand equally little of their intellect.
I enjoy TV. I enjoy movies. I enjoy books. I have not stated a logical paradox in the previous 3 sentences.
Re:TV? What is that? (Score:3)
Re:TV (Score:2)
Re:DirecTivos suck (Score:3, Informative)
On the other hand, you can run dual tuners, which is HUGE. And you can download schedule data from teh satellite instead of having to keep the phone chord plugged in, if it's not a convenient run.
Re:DirecTivos suck (Score:2)
Actually, you don't need the phone cord for stand-alone TiVo's either. You can plug in a USB ethernet or WiFi adaptor and get everything over the internet. I think that you may need the phone for initial setup, but that's it.
Re:DirecTivos suck (Score:2)
This works on all RID based units EXCEPT the R10. To check if you have a RID unit, look on the back, it will have a RID number if it is. Older, non-RID units hav